ProtonVPN vs Mullvad: What We Measured
ProtonVPN is measured on its free servers. The other is on a paid plan.
No affiliate links, no scores out of ten. Both providers run through the same battery on the same machine every six hours, and this page prints the medians - including where they come out about the same.
In short
Measured from one rented server in a datacentre (Kamatera, Toronto), through ProtonVPN in NL and Mullvad in NL, minutes apart, every six hours; the last cycle was aggregated 55 minutes ago.
- Download speed: about the same (580 Mbps against 596 Mbps), inside what the lab can tell apart.
- Latency: about the same (91.6 ms against 90.5 ms), inside what the lab can tell apart.
- Time to connect: Mullvad ahead, 8.0 s against 13.0 s (38% less).
Side by side
| ProtonVPN | Mullvad | |
|---|---|---|
| Download through the tunnel Best of three transfers per cycle, median across cycles. One connection over one route from our server: read it against the other column, not as the most either provider can deliver. |
580 Mbps | 596 Mbps |
| Upload through the tunnel | 378 Mbps | 427 Mbps |
| Download, slowest tenth of runs A tenth of the runs were at or below this. |
465 Mbps | 486 Mbps |
| Upload, slowest tenth of runs | 152 Mbps | 266 Mbps |
| Latency From our server, through the tunnel, to the test endpoint. |
92 ms | 91 ms |
| Time to connect From starting the client to traffic flowing. |
13 s | 8 s |
| Exit flagged as a proxy Share of runs where ip-api.com classified the exit address as a proxy. |
100% | 81% |
| Exit flagged as a datacentre Share of runs where it classified the exit as hosting. |
100% | 100% |
| DNS answered in the exit's own network Share of runs where every resolver that reached our nameserver sat in the same network as the exit. |
100% | 100% |
| Different exit addresses seen | 4 | 25 |
| Server country asked for | NL | NL |
| Cycles behind these figures | 317 | 248 |
Cycle by cycle
Both providers run in the same cycle, minutes apart on the same line, so each cycle is one like-for-like pairing. A median says where the middle is; this counts how often each came out ahead, and by how much in the middle cycle.
- Download: ProtonVPN faster in 70 of 135 cycles, Mullvad in 65; the median gap per cycle was 1.0 Mbps, smaller than the lab treats as a difference.
- Upload: Mullvad faster in 78 of 135 cycles, ProtonVPN in 57; the median gap per cycle was 30 Mbps.
- Latency: Mullvad lower in 179 of 244 cycles, ProtonVPN in 62, level in 3; the median gap per cycle was 1.0 ms, smaller than the lab treats as a difference.
- Time to connect: Mullvad quicker in 171 of 244 cycles, ProtonVPN in 41, level in 32; the median gap per cycle was 5.0 s.
Speed is counted only over cycles in one speed series. Time to connect is read in whole seconds every few seconds, so “level” means within one reading.
Whose network your traffic leaves from
Every run records the network the exit address is registered to. That is all an address says about itself: whether a provider owns that network or rents space in it is not something the stand can see, so this page does not claim either.
ProtonVPN
- Netid (AS49981) in 162 of 317 runs
- NForce Entertainment B.V (AS43350) in 155 of 317 runs
Mullvad
- 31173 Services Netherlands (AS39351) in 155 of 248 runs
- DataCamp Limited (AS212238) in 85 of 248 runs
- Mullvad VPN AB (AS43357) in 8 of 248 runs
DNS followed the exit: the resolvers that answered our lookups sat in the same network as the exit address in 100% of ProtonVPN's measured runs and 100% of Mullvad's. That means the lookups were answered inside the network the traffic left from, not by an outside resolver - measured against our own nameserver. Whether the provider or the network’s owner runs that resolver is not something the stand can see.
What this comparison cannot tell you
- Your speed. A datacentre line is faster than a home one; compare the two columns with each other, not with your connection.
- Either provider’s top speed. Each transfer is one connection over one route from our server, so the speed rows rank the two against each other. For the stand’s first month our own TCP setting capped that connection at about 275 Mbps, and both providers’ best runs stopped there.
- Other countries. Each side is measured through servers in NL; another location can rank differently.
- Streaming. The stand does not test whether either unblocks a service; the proxy flag above is the closest it gets.
- Privacy policy, logging and audits. A measurement shows how a connection behaves, not what a company does with it.
- IPv6 leaks. The stand's server has no IPv6 of its own, so it cannot test them yet.
Check the one you use
These figures describe the providers on our machine. What matters for you is your own connection: the leak test checks IPv4, IPv6, DNS and WebRTC with your VPN on.
🔍 ProtonVPN leak test 🔍 Mullvad leak test 🧪 How the lab measures
ProtonVPN vs Mullvad - FAQ
Answered from the same measurements as the table above.
Which is faster, ProtonVPN or Mullvad?
Download speed: about the same (580 Mbps against 596 Mbps), inside what the lab can tell apart. Cycle by cycle: ProtonVPN faster in 70 of 135 cycles, Mullvad in 65; the median gap per cycle was 1.0 Mbps. Both figures are medians over 188 and 135 cycles on a datacentre line, so the comparison between them holds better than either absolute number.
Does either leak DNS?
In our runs through the tunnel, the resolvers that answered sat in the exit's own network in 100% of ProtonVPN's measured runs and 100% of Mullvad's. A leak on your own device is a different question - the DNS leak test answers it.
Why do some sites say "proxy detected" with a VPN?
Because the exit address is on lists of proxy and datacentre addresses. Our lab records ip-api.com's classification on every run: ProtonVPN's exit was flagged as a proxy in 100% of runs, Mullvad's in 81%.
Is this sponsored?
No. VPNMeter has no affiliate links and takes no payment from providers, and the stand runs the same battery for every provider it measures.
📚 Read next
The longer version: what this test is looking for, and what to do with the answer.